CogniqOS
Subscribe

TRAP #585 ·VOL V The Toolkit · Logical Fallacies & Structured Reasoning

The Original Position Fallacy

Popularised by Gurwinder Bhogal

The audience reshapes the creator. Eventually the creator disappears into the performance.
Category: FallacyEvidence: ReplicatedUniversality: HighTier 1Type: Mechanismⓘ what these mean

This is a Lexicon entry: the mechanism, when it shows up, and the countermeasure. The full correction, with real-world cases and the audit prompt, hasn't been written yet.

Definition

A variation of main character syndrome where people support radical political shifts because they imagine themselves as the elites in the new system.

When it shows up

Debates about radical social change. Political arguments that assume the speaker would land in advantageous positions under the proposed system.

Failure mode

Advocates of radical change unconsciously assume they'd be in the good positions under the new system. The possibility that they'd be in worse positions doesn't enter the calculation. Historical revolutions rarely benefit their early advocates.

Countermeasure

Before endorsing radical change, imagine yourself in a randomly selected position under the new system. Would you still endorse it? If only 'I'm in the good position' works, you're advocating for a system you believe selectively benefits you.

Related traps

Also connected in the map2 more, locked

Credit & first seen

PopularizedCoined/popularized by Gurwinder Bhogal (The Prism - gurwinder.blog). First heard on Modern Wisdom with Chris Williamson () source ↗

Also revealed

Want the full correction for The Original Position Fallacy?

This entry has the mechanism and countermeasure. The full write-up - real cases, sources, the audit prompt - comes later.

Entry #585 of 631 in The Lexicon · see the full Lexicon